Questionnaire example for discrimination claims

Discrimination questionnaires

Questionnaires can be used by employees to get information from their employers about a potential claim. (They can be used either before they bring their claim, or once it has been issued at an Employment Tribunal).

We set out more information about when and how to ask questions here.

The system of “statutory questionnaires” has been abolished for acts of discrimination occurring on or after 6 April 2014. However, you can and should still ask questions of your employer, as this will be important in making your claim as strong as it can be. Acas has issued guidance on how this can be done.

If the Respondent (usually your employer) fails to reply to your questions, or replies evasively, a Tribunal can still take this into account when making a decision in a discrimination claim.

A Tribunal also has the power to order that questions are answered as part of legal proceedings, and in some cases there are other ways of obtaining replies to questions, such as making requests under the General Data Protection Regulation 2018 and the Freedom of Information Act 2000.

Please contact the Working Families helpline if you need more information on this, or if you are unsure about whether or not you can or should use a questionnaire.

Below is an example of how you might set out the background to your situation, and some potential questions to ask, based on the case described in Precedent 1.

Background:

1. I started work for the respondent in March 2008 and I was promoted to hotel manager in August 2019. I never had any disciplinary warnings, verbal or written, throughout my employment.
2. On 1 October 2019, I told the hotel director, Keith Venables, that I was pregnant. Mr Venables congratulated me and said, “You make me think about things”. I did not know what he meant. The comment made me feel uncomfortable at the time.
3. On 4 October 2019, Mr Venables telephoned me and said that business was down and my performance was unsatisfactory. He said he had warned me about this before, which is not true. Then he said, “You don’t know how your pregnancy will go and how you will cope with the workload. You won’t be able to get up early and after eight months, you’ll sleep more”. I was so shocked that I burst into tears.
4. As Hotel Manager, I was normally invited to attend the Group management meetings every month. However, for the first time ever, I was not invited to attend the meetings on 6 and 13 October 2019.
5. On 14 October, Mr Venables sent me an e-mail telling me to attend a disciplinary hearing on 18 October 2019 in respect of my poor performance. I was not informed prior to the hearing of any details as to what was wrong with my performance, and as I had never had any complaints or poor feedback, I had no idea what this could be about. I was not told that I could bring a work colleague with me, contrary to the ACAS Code on Disciplinary and Grievance Procedures. When I asked if I could bring someone with me, I was told that was not necessary.
6. When I attended the hearing, Mr Venables produced statistics showing that hotel occupancy had gone down dramatically in the previous 18 months. I said this was not my fault. It was a result of the global recession. Mr Venables would not listen to me. He said that he could not afford to carry the business and unfortunately he had to replace me. He told me I was dismissed with immediate effect and that a manager from another hotel was coming over to cover. This was not confirmed in writing.
7. My appeal to the Group hotel director on 20 October 2019 was rejected on 22 October 2019.

Questions for employer:

1. What did Mr Venables mean when he said ‘You make me think about things’ when I told him I was pregnant? What concerns did he have about my pregnancy?
2. Please state everything that was wrong with my work performance, including all incidents and evidence (with dates) relied on by the employer in reaching the conclusion that my performance was poor enough to justify dismissal.
3. Please state every occasion, if any, when Mr Venables spoke to me about my work performance with (i) the date (ii) what he was concerned about (iii) what he said.
4. Please give the weekly occupancy rates (i) for the Flamingo Hotel (ii) other UK hotels in the group for the five years prior to the date of answering this questionnaire.
5. In respect of the decision not to invite me to the Group management meetings in October 2019, please state (i) who made this decision, when and for what reasons; (ii) who was consulted, when and what were their views.
6. Please state who represented the Flamingo Hotel at each of the Group management meetings from October 2019 to the date of answering this questionnaire.
7. In respect of the decision to dismiss me, please state (i) who made this decision, when and for what reasons; (ii) who was consulted, when and what were their views. Please share any meeting notes of the decision to dismiss me, and details of each manager and colleague who was contacted regarding my work performance prior to my dismissal, including notes of any calls, meetings or discussions about my performance.
8. In respect of the decision to reject my appeal, please state (i) who made this decision, when and for what reasons; (ii) who was consulted, when and what were their views.
9. Please state who replaced me as manager, when he or she started, and whether it was intended to be a temporary or permanent replacement.
10. In respect of my replacement, please state (i) whether the position was advertised. (If so, where and when?); (ii) if not, how my replacement was selected, when and by whom; (iii) who was consulted regarding this decision, when and what were their views?
11. Regarding my replacement, please state (i) whether it is a man or woman; (ii) if a woman, whether she is pregnant or has young children (giving details); (iii) her qualifications; (iv) her previous experience; (v) if applicable, date and reason for leaving.
12. If there was more than one replacement for me, at the same time or successively, please give the same information as requested at paragraphs 9 – 11.
13. Please state all staff employed (a) within the Flamingo Hotel (b) in other hotels in the UK Group in the three years prior to the date of answering this questionnaire by reference to: (i) start date and if applicable, date and reason for leaving. (ii) job title, department and hotel. (iii) whether male or female (iv) whether they were pregnant or went onto maternity leave at any stage during their employment, giving dates.
14. Please state all staff disciplined or dismissed by the Flamingo Hotel in the three years prior to the date of answering this questionnaire by reference to: (i) job title and department of employee (ii) whether male or female (iii) whether pregnant (iv) whether previously on maternity leave (if so, with dates) (v) level of all disciplinary action and reason (vi) date of all disciplinary action.
15. Please state all employees who have become pregnant or gone onto maternity leave (a) within the Flamingo Hotel (b) in other hotels in the UK Group in the five years prior to the date of answering this questionnaire by reference to: (i) dates of maternity leave (ii) date when notified pregnancy (iii) job title, department and hotel (iv) if applicable, date and reason for leaving hotel (whether dismissed or resigned) (v) if dismissed, reason for dismissal (vi) start date with hotel.
16. Please supply details of your Equal Opportunities Policy and any policy relating to pregnancy or maternity leave, any policies regarding support of parents and carers in the workplace, and details of any training which managers, including my manager, were provided with in the 3 years leading up to my dismissal on equality, diversity, inclusion, and management of staff who are pregnant or are on maternity leave.

You may also wish to ask for a significant amount of background information about your employer’s workforce, to try to establish whether there are factors which tend to show inequality, relevant to your case. For example:

• How many staff overall, and what the gender of those staff is as a whole/at certain levels of management.
• How many grievances have been made in the past 5 years relating to sex discrimination.
• How many claims the employer has received in the past 5 years for sex discrimination
• If there has been a redundancy exercise, which has led to your situation, or if there has been some other workforce change, you may wish to ask questions about the affected employees, and their relevant protected characteristics.

This advice applies in England, Wales and Scotland. If you live in another part of the UK, the law may differ. Please call our helpline for more details. If you are in Northern Ireland you can visit the Labour Relations Agency or call their helpline Workplace Information Service on 03300 555 300.

If you have further questions and would like to contact our advice team please use our advice contact form below or call us.

• 

  Would your employer benefit from support from Working Families?

  Would your employer benefit from some support & guidance from Working Families? If you would like to make your employer aware of how Working Families can help them, we have an introduction letter template available that you can give to the relevant person in your organisation.